In reference to rock journalism, the late Frank Zappa once famously posited that it was ‘written about people who can’t play, for people who can’t read, by people who can’t write.’
Zappa made this observation in 1977 and one can’t help but wonder whether it might be more or less true now than it was then. Either way, Zappa’s epic cynicism would probably be severely strained to accommodate contemporary levels of mendacity. His riposte was witty (there’s a reason why people have been quoting it for the last 41 years) but I must take issue with Frank. I think, or rather I know, that there has been some excellent writing done by people who
can write about people who
can play for people who
can read (amongst whom I number myself, in the third category at least). I’ve been reading about rock music since I were but a wee lad and some of it has been genuinely informative, insightful and moving… but we’ll have to leave that for another day.
The topic of the moment concerns a different medium: Film. Specifically, rock and roll on film. To extend Zappa’s hypothesis: Movies about people who can’t play/act, for people who can’t watch, by people who can’t write/direct? In some cases, undoubtedly, but there have been numerous notable exceptions over the years and some films that arguably rise to the realm of true cinematic greatness. In the early to mid 1950s, before rock and roll had become a fully viable form, there were a few notable films that managed to communicate something of the essential rock and roll attitude. Foremost among them is ‘
The Wild One’ of 1953, the progenitor of the outlaw biker movie genre. Marlon Brando stars as Johnny Strabler, leader of the Black Rebels Motorcycle Club, and in
a classic bit of dialogue he expresses an attitude that extends from early Elvis to the Who to the Sex Pistols to late 20th/early 21st century punk:
Girl: Hey Johnny, what are you rebelling against?
Brando: Whaddya got?
The essence of rock and roll in a nutshell.